Get inspired
In the news
Porcelain Paving vs Natural Stone for Commercial Schemes

Porcelain Paving vs Natural Stone for Commercial Schemes

Ask ten landscape architects whether they'd rather use porcelain paving or natural stone on a commercial job and you'll probably get ten slightly different answers. Most of them will start with "it depends", and they'd be right. It usually comes down to how the space will be used, who is going to look after it, and how much the client values the look of real stone against the practical side of things.

We talk to designers and contractors about this almost every week, so we thought it was worth putting our thoughts down in one place.

Natural stone

Natural stone has been laid outside important buildings for hundreds of years, and it's easy to see why. No two slabs are quite the same, and that variation gives a space a warmth and depth that's hard to recreate. Good sandstone, limestone and granite also age well. After a few years of weather, they often look better than the day they went down, which is exactly what you want outside a civic building or on a heritage site.

The flip side is that stone is a natural material and behaves like one. Some of the softer stones, sandstone and certain limestones in particular, are fairly porous, so a spilt coffee or a drip of oil from a delivery van can leave a mark if the surface hasn't been sealed. Sealing helps, but it needs redoing every so often. Stone is also heavy and usually laid thicker than porcelain, which can become a real issue on a roof terrace or podium deck where the engineer is watching every kilo. And because each quarry batch is a little different, finding a good match for a cracked slab five years down the line isn't always easy.

Porcelain paving

Porcelain paving is made from refined clay fired at very high temperatures, which leaves a dense tile that hardly absorbs any water at all. That one fact explains most of its appeal on commercial schemes. Spills sit on the surface rather than soaking in, so cleaning is straightforward. Frost has very little to grab hold of, so cracking and flaking through a British winter are much less of a worry. The colour doesn't fade in the sun, and because every tile is made to the same spec, what you order for phase two will match what went down in phase one.

It's also lighter and thinner than most stone and sits very happily on pedestal systems, which makes it a natural fit for roof terraces, balconies and podiums.

A few years ago the usual complaint was that porcelain looked flat and a bit artificial. That's not really fair any more. The better outdoor porcelain tiles now copy sandstone, slate and limestone so closely that most people walking over them would assume they were real. Look very carefully and you might spot a pattern repeating here and there, and you won't get the slow weathering that stone gives you. For a busy office plaza or a restaurant terrace, though, most clients are happy to make that trade.

The Kinley range

Kinley supplies both, so you can choose the material that suits the scheme rather than whatever a supplier happens to stock. Everything in the external flooring range can be installed on the Preventa metal, non-combustible RAAFT terrace support system.

Atria® Porcelain Tiles are the workhorse of the range. They come in stone and concrete effects in whites, greys, browns and beiges, and in a wide choice of sizes, from 300 x 600mm planks up to large 1000 x 1000mm and 1200 x 1200mm formats. On a big plaza the larger tiles cut down the number of joints and give a calmer, cleaner finish. The Venice and Arezzo colours have a crisp concrete look that suits modern buildings, while Asti, Florence and Modena lean more towards stone.

Atria® Naturals are for clients who want the look of real stone without the upkeep. They're still porcelain, but the finishes are modelled on sandstone, slate, limestone, granite and basalt. There's a brushed Portland-style limestone in white and beige, flamed granite looks in grey and black, a rustic slate and even a terrazzo, with sizes going up to 1200 x 1200mm. If a client tells you they want stone but the space will take heavy footfall, food and drink, or sits on a roof, these are well worth showing them.

Carva Stone Flooring is Kinley's natural stone range, covering sandstone, limestone and granite. The colours run from the warm ochre of Cairo sandstone and the pale Aswan limestone through to the dark Black Ocean and a set of granites in light grey, dark grey, blue grey and yellow grey. It's the one we'd point people towards for a grand entrance, a heritage-led project, or anywhere the client wants a surface that will gain character as it ages.

Making the call

If the space is going to be busy, involves food and drink, sits on a structure, or needs to look smart for years with very little maintenance, porcelain paving is usually the sensible choice. If the setting is historic or high profile and there's a proper maintenance plan in place, natural stone earns its place.

Plenty of schemes end up using both. Stone goes at the main entrance where it makes the biggest impression, and porcelain covers the terraces and seating areas that take the most wear.

Whichever way you go, make sure the product is actually made for outside use. A lot of people searching for porcelain tiles outdoor Not all porcelain is made for outside. Outdoor porcelain tiles are thicker than the ones in a bathroom, typically [20mm], and have a textured finish for grip in the wet, so check the slip rating [R11 or above] against where they’re going, particularly around entrances and ramps. In the same way, if you choose stone, find out early whether it will need sealing. Lighter sandstones and limestones in busy areas usually do, while granite tends to be tougher.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is porcelain paving slippery when wet?+

Point to the slip rating and the textured external finish.

Does porcelain paving need sealing?+

No. Contrast this with the softer sandstones and limestones.

Can porcelain paving be laid on pedestals?+

Yes, and mention RAAFT.

Does porcelain paving crack?+

It can under point loads if the bedding is poor or the pedestals are spaced wrongly. This also gives the porcelain section the honest drawback it’s missing.

Is porcelain paving cheaper than natural stone?+

Most competing guides cover cost and the draft doesn’t. I’d only include this if Kinley is happy to give a view on price.

Get in touch

Every project has its own quirks, from the build-up and loads to the budget and how people will actually use the space. If you'd like to talk it through, book a consultation with Kinley's technical team or download the technical drawings. You can also browse the full external flooring range.

READY TO TACKLE YOUR PROJECT NO MATTER SIZE, SHAPE, OR CHALLENGE?

Get in touch with us today!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.
Kinley Systems orange kinley shape